Friday, October 08, 2010

MOVED

I have moved my weblog to : 

Genesis 9:2-4 Ministries

I have decided to keep this version of the weblog available for archival purposes.  The new site is built on Wordpress, and it has a whole lot of features that a simple weblog did not have.

Thanks to Blogspot and Blogger for giving me a good home since 2004.  I really could not have asked for much more from you guys.

Please, drop into the new site and check it out.

Friday, October 01, 2010

Playing the Wind or J-Lo and Steve find each other?

From the D&DH Forum


Cut N' Run



If deer always walked into the wind in Fall, wouldn't they all eventually end up in the Pacific northwest? Just kidding.

This all reminds me of a story:

O.D and Playing the Wind

As usual, I'm going take a completely contrary approach to all this.  I guess it's just in me.  But now that I'm starting to look at 30 years as a deer hunter, I guess I can start speaking with at least the appearance of authority-- either that or the appearance of foolishness. The older I get, the more these seem to appear the same.


I have to a large extent given up on the idea of playing the wind. I have stands that have been up now for going on a decade. I have hunted them under all conditions. Some stands probably have undergone a hundred sittings or more, and I cannot count the hours I have sat glassing the open pastures. If there is a direct correlation to wind direction and deer movement I don't see it. Oh, I know its there, but I just do not see it. I think I know why.

Any drunk will tell you it's Happy Hour somewhere in the world all the time. A good drunk will always have a list of holidays for every day of the year. The plain truth is, on a round planet everywhere is upwind of something else. Similarly, deer are everywhere. I will not say they randomly spread across the countryside, but they do wander around quite a bit. Patterns? Yes, there are patterns. There are resident doe groups that lead pretty regular lives. However, there are also a lot of deer moving from outside your immediate area onto the the property you are hunting, and those who we think of as residents do a lot of wandering of their own. The net of all this is a fairly chaotic picture. Keep this in mind as we go through things. I'll come back to it in a bit.

Then again.. . Let's say you have a really pat setup. I can remember one such setup. It was a peninsula stretching out into a cornfield. When their were crops in the field, the resident deer always used that peninsula to get into the corn. All tracks going into that corn were either to or from the peninsula, and at one point there was a 10-foot corridor at the base of the peninsula where the deer cut across a creek. I hunted that structure for several years. Wind? The deer could not care less. They came from acres around to feast on the corn or sometimes soybeans that were in that field. They came at dawn. They came at dusk. They always walked across the creek at that one point.

Now you have to ask yourself? What did the deer do when the wind changed? The other side of the corn field was a main road and a farm house (Trivia: That farmhouse used to be where Nick and Nina Clooney lived-- George's parents.) There was a junior high on another side. What? They were going to do an end-around from their beds and go through the junior high parking lot, slip across Mason Montgomery road and come in past Nick's house? Yeah, right. What did I do? I hunted that peninsula in all kinds of conditions. I changed up my approach from one trip to the next. However, I was always within 50 yards of that choke point on the creek. Yes, sometimes the deer winded me, but usually I set up one side of the corridor or the other. Did it make any difference which side of the corridor I set up? No, because I never knew which way the deer would approach the corridor-- upwind, downwind, or crosswind.

Now let's go back to that random deer thing. I know a lot of you think I'm speaking heresy. However, the deer rarely seem to cooperate with me. Maybe I'm special. If I do all my planning aforehand and pick the most likely spot the deer will come given the weather conditions at hand, I can be well assured that when the deer show up, they'll be coming from another direction. The deer I was planning for? They may have decided to go somewhere else for the next couple of days. Their friends from the other ridge have wandered in, and they see a great opportunity to feed on the acorns the other deer have left. They started out the day in a bed somewhere else, and see the oak grove I'm hunting from a completely different angle. Upwind? Downwind? Are they going to circle around the oak grove and go 500 yards out of their way just to be sure I'm not in a tree, or are they going to just go for it?

Look at it a different way. Last night I was making the haul back from S.Central KY up I-75 to Cincinnati. About 10 O'Clock, I got hungry. About that time I saw a Skyline Chili sign, and I started thinking about a Chilito. I took the exit and drove straight to the place. I didn't circle around looking for a better way in. I didn't worry about the bus full of nuns that I nearly ran off the road. I went for it. Do you really think deer do any differently? By the way, tell the nuns I'm sorry. It was a Skyline thing-- they'll understand.

It's always going to be upwind somewhere. One deer's upwind is another's downwind, and if deer get an urge to go eat, they are probably not going to get really, really cagey about how they get there. Your mileage may vary, but that is how I am beginning to see it.

So, if I'm so against reading the wind, what am I for? Structure. More and more, I see the basic topography dictating more about deer movement than anything. When you couple fairly gross topological features with cover and food, there is a package that will dictate the vast majority of deer movement.

With some planning and quite a bit of perseverance, I have found structures on my farm where deer habitually move. It may be a point here, a hint of a shelf there. It may be a saddle, or just the closest approach of two creek systems for miles around. These seem to produce predictable deer movement more than anything. That is, if I post myself in sight of one of these structures, I will see deer. Add the predictability of their penchant for showing up at dawn and dusk, and the odds go up even more.

Add wind? That's what I want to know. How can I add wind when I can never see a predictable pattern to it. I can post on a given structure. Watch the sun go up or down. The deer will show or not. Nowadays, I seldom go a whole sitting without seeing at least one deer. After nearly 3 decades, I can't say if that is because I have become a great deer hunter, or that there are just a lot more deer running around than there were when Regan was president. I suspect it is a combination of both.

Give me the benefit of the doubt here, and assume the deer show up. If they do show, they're not going to come from a predictable direction. Their noses aren't to the wind or against it. I have had deer regularly show up from 3 directions to converge on the same spot. Do I get busted? Yes, not as much as before I took the mothballs out of my pockets, but I still do on occasion. Now that I am washing my stuff in baking soda and making a point to bathe myself on hunting trips, I see a lot more deer. I get busted, but it is usually from a combination of sight and sound and smell. Beyond a certain level, I know I cannot control my odor after I leave the house, therefore I concentrate on the other two and try to move as little as possible.

This has all been written from the perspective of a stand hunter. What about other methods? It all applies, but it applies in different ways. On the ground, it is all still true, only more so. If you're in a ground blind, or still hunting, the chances of getting winded are higher. I have only to look at my own experience with this, and I am sure you will agree; for every deer that comes to you on a upwind quarter there are at least one or two that come from a downwind quarter. Did they somehow sense you and circle around to double check? Are they that canny? I doubt it. Most deer stumble through life the same way we do. They were just lucky they stumbled in just the right way. We're not talking about cervid master-minds here. These are dumb deer, probably no smarter than your average viewer of American Idol or WWE.

For going on 10 years now, I've been bringing guests out to the farm and taking them on walking tours. Some are hunters. Some are not. Usually whatever we're up to, it takes us past one or more of my treestands. Most times I tell people that there are treestands around, and they are tasked with trying to spy them. The result? Most people cannot see a treestand outside of close bow range. Most have to have them pointed out. Some need me to go up and touch it. Often times we bump into deer. The deer have a nearly similar track record. Sure, some will bolt away at 200 yards snorting madly, but for each one of those stories, I've got one to match it like the deer that I walked up on holding a flashlight last fall. (That was me holding the flashlight. Wow! J-Lo gonna be a judge this year-- ain't that the shizz?) . . . or the buck that followed me down the road a few years ago. I don't know what that deer had on his mind! It must have been Hulk Hogan putting that smackdown on Andre the Giant. I know it rocked my world and left me stunned for weeks.

Stalking? Look, I'm a walking landform (Think John Wayne gone to seed) Do you really want to take the word of a guy who has Size 14 shoes on how to stay quiet and go unobserved in the woods? If so, I have an inside tip for you: J-Lo  is secretly in love with Steven Tyler, but doesn't know how to tell him. Look for the subtle signs this year. I'm sure you'll see them. Take it from a guy who's gone through five presidencies hanging out in trees-- the wind is not the most important thing out there.

One last story: One night, I was coming out from hunting. I was parked in the apron of the farmhouse (Nick and Nina's place) . Nick and Nina were long gone, and my buddy had rented it out to another family. It was a cold, frosty, November night and Jupiter was high in the sky. I pulled out my binoculars and started looking at Jupiter , and was treated to one of the best views of the planet I'd ever seen. I was able to see the 4 Galilean moons very clearly. It moved me deeply. About this time the guy who lived there came out to say hello.

"Whatcha doing?" he asked. I put down my binoculars, still reeling in the sublime moment. There were the 4 moons that showed Galileo that there was a world more wonderful and wider than the Universe described by Aristotle and held as gospel by the Church. It meant we were not the center of the Universe. It was one of the greatest realizations a man had ever had, and there I was seeing it fresh again, as it had been the first time.

"I've been watching Jupiter." I said. "This is great. You want to have a look?"

"Sure." I passed him the glasses and pointed out Jupiter.

"See the moons?" I asked. There was a long pause, followed by an even longer one. Finally the fellow put down the binos and handed them back to me.

"All them pretty lights," he said. "Them's stars, ain't they?"

"Yes," I replied.

"Thought so." he said. Without another word, he went back inside to watch TV.

I submit to you all that most deer do not surpass the tenant's level of intelligence. Given the chance to travel upwind, downwind, or whatever, most will chose with the deftness of the Turtle and ostensible wisdom of the Opossum to take the path that offers the shortest, flattest path to a good meal or a good bed. The rest? I dunno. Judge Judy's coming on soon. I gotta go.

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Transporting your Deer

Kenn wrote:
"...I just got my lic and permit to hunt a deer this fall. I'm using a 40lb recurve and have a place to hunt up near Marysville. I'm still a bit vague on field dressing, processing stations and such. For instance, with a small to med sized buck, will I be able to transport it in the back of my Matrix or do I need to get a truck? Do you have any sage advice?"

Congratulations! Finding a good spot to hunt is sometimes the hardest part of the whole thing. I was a bit vague on field dressing too. Go on Youtube and search "kyafield deer dressing" There's a great video there-- not quite the way I do it, but it'll work.

Hmmmm. Now we come to the part about the Matrix. Frankly I wouldn't let Morpheus catch you out roaming around. Agent Smith is everywhere these days. If you're comprimised, they may be able to trace your connection all the way back to Zion. . .

. . . Oh, you mean THAT kind of Matrix. You should be okay. However, I would make sure you have enough room in the back for all your gear AND the deer. Also, carry a 10X12 tarp to wrap the deer in. Once you're done cleaning there will always be some blood and it's a bear to get out of your trunk. You may also want to think about keeping something like duffel bags handy to take some of your gear up on the luggage rack for the ride home.

Whatever you do, don't pull the old trick of trying to tie the deer off on the hood. For one thing it really screws up the meat-- all that wind and the heat from the engine. Secondly, it is really poor taste to go around with a deer in the open. I (of course) don't mind seeing dead deer, but a lot of people take great offense, and there's really no point being in-your-face about it.

Good luck!!! Take lots of pictures.

Thursday, September 09, 2010

The Deer Family

So I see the guy who does my hay has been out and started work. He's late getting started. So first thing last night after returning to the farm, I go out in the truck to see how far he's gotten-- not far, but it is a good start. I was particularly interested in seeing if he'd managed to Rotovate the new food plot. The answer was no. Oh well.

I drive into the pasture that will hold the new plot . About halfway along here comes a doe and two fawn in through an opening in the fence and straight out into my path about 40 yards away. The dog and I were transfixed. The doe didn't seem to mind in the least. She was on her way across the pasture at its narrowest point and took a few steps here and there, but mostly flicked her tail and just took in the sights of a pleasant September evening.

I let my foot off the break for a moment and rolled forward to throw it in Park. That did not faze her, nor her two kids. Then I saw him. There was this big 10 pointer following them. He jumped the fence a few feet closer to the truck and came into the field and stood-- biggest deer I've seen on the place in almost two years. None of these 4 deer had the least bit of interest in my truck, myself or the dog, and the doe was only mildly annoyed by the buck's presence. They dawdled going across the pasture and disappeared.

Normally, I'd be thinking the doe and fawns would be hanging with another doe if anything. The buck? This is a tad early in the season for the bucks to be thinking about noogie. The relationship seemed entire platonic, too. It made feel old to watch them. The thought occurred to me how long its been since I had a toddler in the car oogling deer and talking in terms of "mommy deer" and "daddy deer."

It has also been probably 25 years since I finally figured out a basic truth about deer behavior was sheer rubbish. I don't know how many of you all started out with this idea but when I started deer hunting, it was widely held that if you see a doe deer, the important thing was to stay completely still, because the bucks send the doe out ahead to scout, poking them in the rear with their antler to get them to cross into the open spaces. I don't know how many doe I let slip by over the first few years of hunting waiting for that big buck I knew was lurking in the bushes. It took 30 years to finally see it come to pass.

Monday, August 30, 2010

A Ninety-Niner Speaks Out about Deer Hunting

 From Deer and Deer Hunting: For the Ninety -Niners



It's funny.  I don't think a lot of guys get it.  It could be that my hillbilly girlfriend's all-to-subtle ways are rubbing off on me, and I'm getting so subtle no one can catch my hints anymore.  It could be as well that I'm the only Ninety-Niner on here.  I doubt it.  I just think most folks are trying to lay low on it.  Shoot!  It could be no one else even knows what a Ninety-Niner is, or how it relates to deer hunting.

Let me explain:  If you've been on unemployment so long that your state and federal benefit has run out, you're a Ninety-Niner.  The name comes from the Ninety-Nine weeks (just under 2 years) of benefits received.    I lost my job in July of '08. I fell off the back end of the system this past  June.  I didn't know I was a Ninety-Niner until a few weeks ago. That's when I heard the term used for the first time.  We aren't considered unemployed anymore, so we don't count towards that 9.5% unemployment rate. We're . . . we're. . . we're just Ninety-Niners. 

Ninety-Niners are not worthless lazy bums who got kicked off the dole.  Fox News reported that 50-something managers like me in hi-tech professions probably are never going to work again.  A company can't refuse us health benefits anymore, so we're just too much of a risk. I was let go a month shy of 50, and all my 49 year old cohorts were chased out or let go all in their 49th year-- thank federal guidelines for age discrimination starting at 50 for that.

So what does this have to do with deer hunting?  It has a lot to do with deer hunting this season, at least for me.  Being a Ninety-Niner will probably affect my deer hunting for years to come.  This year, I can still afford tags and still afford the trips to Kentucky to hunt. We can still keep the farm. Next year?  We'll see.  So far the truck has kept running.  The point is I know I'm feeling quite a bite.  Reloading?  All my big projects are on hold.  Gun acquisitions?  You got to be kidding. Bowhunting?  I'd already gotten my medical waiver to hunt with a crossbow, because of my shoulder.  I was at the new doctor's last week to discuss it (the old one had responded to the onset of Obamacare by demanding $1,500 cash before he'd see you)  The new doc is talking surgery and rehab, while I'm just trying to budget for extra ibuprofen. 

I'm probably not the only Ninety-Niner on here, and this is not the first time I have had to deal with a downturn in the economy and getting laid off going into season. As a result, I'm doing my best to talk about it, and I hope it does some good.

Take the Baking Soda-- The Shamanic Method thread as a for-instance.  I didn't want to just get right in folks' face, but let's be blunt.  If you're unemployed and you still think of yourself as a deer hunter, you're probably looking for ways to economize.  Some folks are appreciating the advice and saying so.  However, some folks have inadvertently hijacked the thread here and there-- once to discuss some kind of carbon sprinkles, and another to discuss Scent-Lok and various other products.  The point is that it is obvious y'all have jobs and aren't thinking the same.  It's a difference in mindset.  For some, washing hunting clothes at $.10/load is a big deal, and  $8 can be either spent on sprays removing invisible rays from your clothing or it can be spent on a youth tag.  Ninety-Niners are looking for no-cost or low-cost methods.

Two years out of work changes your perspective. Eventually you come to see those thoroughly entrenched in the hunting establishment as foreign.  Larry Weishuhn is a fine upstanding deer hunter, but a Ninety-Niner might think about throwing something at the screen if he has to sit through too many 30-minute infomercials for the Thompson Center Encore.   Ditto for all those folks who came back from Shot Show this year, and couldn't wait to tell us about the wonderful feeling they had running up their leg over Remington and Ruger's new offerings.  I ain't bitter, but  . . .

 . . .let's just say the arrival of the big NEW GEAR issues along with the Cabela's catalog were not the big event they used to be.  Walmart dropping their price on underwear and tube socks was. 

For some, there just is not going to be enough they can spend to get that winning edge this year.  A federal judge has declared Scent-lok's advertising fraudulent, but there will be some that won't think twice about plunking down $300 for a new set. For others,  the idea of taking RIT dye to take out the fading in their old camo coveralls may be a godsend.  That is a huge and growing disparity.  Meanwhile the deer don't care if you're wearing HD, 4D or 1.5D camo.  Fact of the matter is I filled my tags wearing brown duck Carharts.

I'm not trying to be coy about this anymore.  If you can't afford a new ghillie suit or even a new hunting coat, take your old work coat and give it the baking soda treatment.  Then go out to the fabric store-- bring your wife or girlfriend if it will make you feel better.  Buy 2 yards of cotton duck camo.  Put a hole in it, the way I described in the thread on ponchos and have your woman hem it up for you.  I hunted that way for years.  I didn't have dedicated cold weather hunting duds for the first 20 years of hunting, but I did have a green freezer suit from working in the frozen cheeseburger factory, and I could afford $10 worth of close-out camo fabric.

You don't need Barnes TSX or Federal Premium or Hornady Custom to kill a deer.  Forget the fancy poly carbonate nosecones and all the other plow-whistles.  Watch the ads.  Remington Corelokt and Winchester Power Points go on sale. They will kill deer just fine.  I used Remington Sluggers for years in my shotgun.  They kill just fine. Don't let ammunition costs keep you home.  Lordy, if you look at the price of beef and the price of a resident tag. . .Last season, I bagged two doe that went +170lbs  live weight, and I was glad I went for the meat rather than holding out hope for antlers.  Frankly, I've got several racks sitting around the house that are waiting for the taxidermist, but it may be years before they're staring back at me from the mantle.

I may be all wrong.  It may just be our deodorants, but I've noticed a lot less traffic on here this year than previous years.  It may be the Ninety-Niners are giving up on hunting, not buying tags and not hitting the forums any more.  It is a shame if it is so.  D&DH magazine relies heavily on ad revenue, so I am sure there won't be much in the way of homebrew solutions and make-do articles the way there was back in the Thirties.  Back then Outdoor Life had an article a month on that sort of thing-- building your own knapsack to building your own cabin to repairing your own waders.

Nobody is going to use an old pant leg for a quiver (except me).  Probably no one will want to read about using a wheel barrow inner tube for a ground cushion.   On the forum, however, we've got more latitude.  JPH's forum piece on doing a homebrew camo job was  spot-on.  MSBadger's cardboard deer blind was right there. I always was a bit of a shade-tree gunsmith.  Here's a pic from my piece two seasons ago. Yes, that's a 1/4-20 hex bolt on the scope:



. . . and here's Angus' custom youth rifle:



The whole project cost under $80. For some, a cheek piece made from duct tape is a joke.  For my kid, it meant having a deer rifle that fit him.  This year it got re-stocked and I taught Angus how to refinish.  That was our big father/son project over the summer.

I didn't mean to rain on anyone's parade with this rant.   I figured if I came out straight on it, y'all would understand. My only advice to D&DH is that if you're stuck for ideas a Ninety-Niner's Guide to Deerhunting might be a good one.  I'd offer to edit it.  This sport can no longer be about the cargo we carry and the cargo we consume.

Sunday, August 29, 2010

Bambi Killer!!!

James P. Reilly: Bambi killer

 

Remember James, If the Good Lord had not wanted us to eat deer, he would not have made them out of meat.

Yes, I kill Bambi. Mostly I try to kill Bambi's aging grandfather, Bambi's spinster aunts and his older sisters. However, if Bambi shows up on the wrong day, he may get it. The sad thing of it is that about 50% of the herd's new cohort suffer mortality in the first year. Some of that is due to hunting, but there are a whole slew of other causes.

Bambi ( the antlerless bucks) and Bambi's Mom (dominant females) are my least favorite targets. It's fairly obvious why Bambi is not a good idea: you want the young bucks to survive long enough to grow into big bucks. In these parts, a big mature buck may go 300 lbs live weight and yield 90 lbs of venison. Little Bambi might only yield 20 lbs. Sadly, It is hard to tell Bambi from a young doe, especially at a distance and especially in low light. There are behavioral cues, but sometimes. . . well, sometimes things don't go as planned. The good news is that Bambi tastes about as good as you're going to get.

Bambi's Mom is another story. Deer are very matriarchal . The does have a hierarchy. The older does have a lot of experience in rearing young and keeping the doe herd safe and well fed. You'll see doe in little herds of 3-7 individuals, and these are usually a mature doe, her daughters and their fawns. Taking out the lead doe in one of these herds leads to considerable stress and confusion in the group. The better tactic is to shoot for the second doe in a group, or one in the middle. The trailers are often times buck fawns (Bambi).

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Baking Soda-- the Shamanic Method

Jake Simon August 12 at 3:36am
Shaman,

I hope all is well with you and yours!
I am curious as to how you use baking soda. Do you dump it on everything or do you just put it in with your clothing like you would use it in your refrigerator?
I am looking to try using it this year and am looking for any tips you would kindly share.

His Blessings,
Jake


Thanks for asking. Now that Scent-Lok has been unmasked, I was meaning to write something about how to kick it up old school.  My method is based on an article I read probably 25 years ago. Prior to reading the article, I was going afield in wool that stank of moth balls and I smoked a pipe on the stand.  I got turned around and got headed in a better direction immediately.  Back at that time, there were no special Scent-Lok clothes and no scent killing sprays.  I was frankly surprised when those all came on the market few years later.  Baking soda seemed like such an simple, easy solution.  A little bit of the stuff does an amazing job. 

First let me talk about what goes on before the baking soda gets used.  Right now I have a pile of dirty hunting clothes down the basement .  Yes, it might be better if they were all stored in scent-tight tubs and all that. The point is that dirty clothes, left since turkey season can be cleaned up.  Just don't let them mildew. 

Second, let me talk about the baking soda itself.  Baking soda, sodium bicarbonate, is used in baking and in certain industrial processes.  It is a gentle alkaline.  The exact reason for its effectiveness on odor is unclear. However, I have used it on everything from cat pee to pit stink to cigar smoke.  If you can get it on the scent and you're willing to let sodium bicarbonate take its sweet time, it will take anything out of anything.  Buying it in the supermarket in little yellow boxes gets a little expensive.  However, for years I was able to find large sacks of the stuff at the local chemical supply house.  It ended up costing me about $0.10 a load and a sack would last me three years or more.  Most recently I found a good cheap source at Sam's Club next to the flour.  It isn't quite as cheap as the 80lb sack, but it is still cheaper than laundry detergent.


As a detergent, it is not all that good, but nobody really wants their clothes bright and shiny when they are deer hunting anyway.  If I walk through heavy wet clay and get mud stains on my pants, sodium bicarbonate will not take out the stains right away, but over time the clay and just about everything else leaves.  Blood?  If I get blood on my hunting clothes, I wash in regular detergent and then give them the sodium bicarb treatment I am about to describe.  I use unscented detergent anyway. UV?  Sodium bicarb has absolutely no UV brighteners.  It will also keep you immune to elephant attack and alien abduction.  Don't get me started on this UV hooey again!


First I take a cup of baking soda and throw it in the washing machine and send it through one short cycle  empty.  If I have some clothes that had blood on them, I may throw those in too to wash out any remaining detergent.  This cleans out the machine, and gets it ready for the subsequent loads.

Sort your clothes  in the following way:   Outer layers to inner layers.  Do the outer layers first. The theory is the most amount of human scent will be on the innermost layers.  In the first load, I'll do jackets, bibs, pants, etc.  In the last load, I put in underwear.   You have to understand I have two sons hunting with me, and that is a lot of wash.  It is okay if you just have one load, but if you are going to have to split it up, best to have it segregated.  I usually do my socks as a separate load no matter what; I can line-dry them indoors too.

Add a cup or so of baking soda to each load. Wash on Cold/Cold with nothing but the sodium bicarb.  If  you can catch the load as it is going into the last rinse cycle,  throw in another half-cup of sodium bicarb as it is filling.  Otherwise when it is all done,  go back and then run a separate rinse cycle and add in baking soda.  This puts some extra chemical into the fabrics before you dry them.  This extra dose of sodium bicarb may or may not be necessary.  If I'm packing clothes away for a long time, I may not do it; the dry chemical will have time to work on them over the intervening weeks.  If these are clothes I will be certain to wear the next week, I'll definitely try to hit them with the extra dose.

When a load is done, I take it outside to the back yard and hang them up on the line until dry.  This is usually not a problem in the summer, but as the season wears on it can be a pain.  The trick is to find enough time between Sunday night and the next Friday to get the clothes dry. If it is going to be raining in the early part of the week,  I may hold off doing the wash until Wednesday.  I have even packed wet clothes down to camp to dry.  It is a problem, but it has to be done.  Do not let the clothes dry in a dryer.  Do not hang them up in places where they will pick up a lot of extraneous scent.  A normal suburban back yard is usually okay, but watch out for your grill and smoker.  In a pinch I have used my garage.

After stuff is dry, I pack everything in either a plastic leaf bag or a plastic tub.  Tubs are nice, but when I'm trying to jam gear into the back of my truck, they are not necessarily the easiest to fit.  Bags compress well. As I am packing the dry clothes away, I'm sprinkling a little bit of baking soda as I go.  Into one big bag of clothes I may put half a handful or so.  When I was first doing this regimen, I was always overdoing this part of it.  It really does not require all that much.  Again, if you have the chance to do so, keep the outer layers separate from the inner layers.   Keep socks separate.  In fact, I usually throw them in a plastic grocery bag and take them in my regular baggage.


Now for me.  Before each hunt I try and take a shower and use sodium bicarb either as a replacement for or as a touch-up after soap and shampoo.  When I'm done, I throw a bit of it into my still-wet hair, work a pinch under the armpits and into my crotch and then give myself a quick dusting of the stuff while I am still somewhat wet.  Then I towel off.  Here is another place where I used to go wild with the sodium bicarb.  It does not take all that much.

I try not to reuse clothing, and especially not the innermost layers.  Down at the camp, I eat breakfast in my long-johns and then dress out on the front porch.  When I come back in the outer layer I might want to reuse later in the day gets hung up to air outside. Boots are not worn in the house and get a pinch of sodium bicarb in them between uses.  Any clothes that are done for the day are taken off and put in a leaf bag for the trip home.


I have a set of insulated camo, a coat and bibs, as well as a set of boot blankets, a wool balaclava, and wool sweater that never see a washing machine.  In fact, I have had all three for 7 seasons and they have never been cleaned or washed.  However, I wear them throughout the latter part of deer season. These present a challenge, but sodium bicarb will do wonders used dry.  What I do is air out the clothing immediately after use.  After that, I pack them in their own nylon duffel with sodium bicarb.  I pay particular attention to the crotch of the bibs and the armpits of the coat and sweater.  Over the intervening week, the baking soda does its magic. A couple of years, turkey season has been cold and snowy starting out.  I used these clothes for a week or two in the Spring, aired them out, packed them away in baking soda and they were just fine come fall.

Another trick I use keeps these outer layers from getting soaked in sweat and acquiring a stink.  Let's say it's down around 32F and it's still an hour or so before sunrise. I take everything that constitutes my outermost layer, stored in its own duffel and schlep it out to the stand IN the duffel.  This is one of those heavy nylon duffels they issue to the troops.  It has pack straps.  The duffel is a bit bulky, but it is relatively light and it beats wearing all that stuff on my body. I go out to my stand dressed in something like uninsulated bibs and a sweater. The weather is cold enough that I don't have to worry about working up a sweat.  I get into the stand, haul up the duffel and climb into the last layer. Not only do I keep from sweating (and stinking), but I stay warmer as well.



How effective is my  method?  I have been busted at 200 yards by a deer downwind when I was not observing any scent control.  I have also had deer bust me on the upwind side of a stand at 70 yards. When I'm doing everything I can with the baking soda, deer pay absolutely no attention to me-- upwind or downwind.  I have been on the ground and had deer practically walking on me.  Last year, I went through all season with only one hard bust on the stand, and this was a doe that caught me standing up to stretch.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Burn Out

From the D&DH Forum:


DeerCamp
Super Member



Deer season is long, but as you all know the off season is even longer. My question is this, with all the books, DVD’S, magazines, and countless numbers of deer strategies out there, do any of you ever get “burned out?” Here in Michigan, there is about 51 days till bow season. I have all my stands placed accordingly, and feel good about their location. However I continue to read and watch all sorts of hunting related material. How do you cope with a “burn out?” It seems after all my hours and hours of thinking about deer, I have this “burnt out” feeling and the season hasn’t even started yet. Do any of you ever feel this and how to you cope with it? I try to put down the book, or watch a different show rather than hunting, but it seems nothing of interest to me.


I mean deer season in Michigan is 93 days long. Now I know I won’t be able to hunt every single day but believe me I will be able to hunt over 60 days with my current school/ work schedule..I couldn’t help but wonder if any of you ever get this feeling? I’m sure most do during the end of the season, however what about the so called “pro’s.” One would think they would want some time off as well..

But don’t get me wrong I love hunting, I just hate this feeling.

I know exactly what you're talking about.  It does not happen to me as much any more, at least not the acute form of it.  Burn out has been a regular feature of my deer hunting experience.  It probably always will be.

The problem, as I see it, is that deer hunting in itself is a rather boring activity.  It requires massive amounts of pre-planning, expense, etc.  However, when you finally get it all put together, and your butt goes into the seat on the treestand on Opening Day. . .

. . . nothing.    Furthermore, as I faced in a lot of years, nothing happens all season.  Sure, the sun comes up, tracks across the sky and finally sets.  The squirrels come and go.  You have lots of birds, but the actual time you have with deer in sight could be counted some years for me in seconds.  No sane man could do this week after week and not get to rethinking what he is doing out in the woods on a perfect beautiful October day.  He really gets to questioning that sanity when the warm days of October slowly erode into the pin cushion pre-dawn freezing rain of November.  By the time shotgun season rolls around in December, he promises himself that he will get out and stay out for good. But first he must pray to his absent and bitter god to help him get his butt unstuck from that blasted metal seat to which it is now caught in frozen embrace.

I see this process as a trajectory.  Your will power is a rocket.  Your enthusiasm for the sport is the fuel.  Your target needs to be the end of season.  You now know about how much energy you have to expend on your sport.  You know what kind of drag can be exerted on it by family, work, etc.  Eventually your will is going to be spent.  The problem is timing it so that you give out about the time season runs out.  That may mean deliberately starting later in the year to get ready. It may mean rationing the amount of hunting shows you watch.  Every deer hunter needs to manage this. 

Me?  Look, I'm the guy who went so far into this that I made Deer Camp a year-round lifestyle. Most weekends I'm down there doing something related to deer and turkey. My deer and turkey have names. Eventually something has to give.  What I have done to manage my will power is this:

1)  I do not hunt deer in September.  KY's archery season starts the first weekend in September.  I wait until at least Oct 1 to start hunting.  I don't like fighting the heat, and the deer are generally not around anyway.  I focus my efforts on specific parts of the season-- Mid-October to Thanksgiving.  That is when the deer hunting is at its best, and I can get the freezer filled without a lot of muss and fuss.  I also don't hunt in January any more.  Part of it is that I've paid my January dues.  I know what it's like to lose feeling in my extremities.  The other reason is coming.

2)  I try and give myself a deliberate break.  When I'm done, I'm done. After I get  out of the woods, shut down camp, and finish my Christmas shopping, I get my rifles cleaned up and go sit on the couch.  I try not to think about it again for a while.  Usually the weather is most cooperative.  Right about the time I'm ready to hang it up, Cincinnati weather has a way of telling me I am making a wise choice. Twice, I've had to make a mad dash back down to camp-- once at 1AM-- to get the water drained before The Big One hit. The power on our road at camp can be off for over a month at a time in the Winter.  I usually pick up watching NFL Football during the last week of regular season and watch it through to the Super Bowl. Somewhere around there I get out my turkey calls and my shotgun.

3)  Usually my deer hunting jag starts in July.  It happens when I get trapped inside at home for a couple of weekends, because it is just too darn hot.  About that time the Fall catalogs arrive.  I get twitchy.  I know better than to try and feed it-- at least let the throttle go wide-open.  If I did, I would be insufferable to my family, worthless at work and I would be burned out by October 1.  Rather, I let the bug hit  and start off with a managed plan.   Today, I'm teaching #3 son the rudiments of stock refinishing.  Tomorrow, we're going to do some reloading together.  Within the week, I'm going to have a couple of loads of deer clothes washed and packed.  A little here and a little there goes a long way. 

4)  I've given up on TV, outside of D&DH.  I DVR it and watch the episodes a little later in the year.  I also save up a stack of magazines and don't start reading them when they first arrive.  After nearly 30 years of this, there really isn't anything all that new anyway.  Media just adds gasoline to the fire.

5)  Budgets:  I set a number and try to stick to it, and I try to squeeze as much out of a tight budget as I can.  Well before season I have a target of what I want. I know when the stuff goes on sale, and I'm watching a few sites waiting to strike.  I hold off on hitting BassPro at the mall and doing all my window shopping and impulse buying until I have the big stuff nailed down.  This keeps the whole thing throttled back.  To many lunch hours at too many sporting goods stores gave me an empty wallet and a bad case of pre-season burnout.

6)  If it ain't right, it ain't right.  If it gets to the last week in October, and I see a 3 day rain coming on and I've got deer in the freezer and I'm getting over a cold, I no longer throw the cough syrup and cold pills into the duffel and head out.  I did.  I did for years. I don't anymore.  I've gone hunting with my foot wrapped in bandages. I've come out of the stand and changed into a business suit for a meeting.  I've picked ticks out of my scalp in board rooms.  Not anymore. I try and be the Taoist sage and go with the flow of things.


Despite all these measures, I've found myself at Zero-minus-Forty on the Opener,  sitting in the pre-dawn gloom wondering what the heck I was doing, a grown man with a family and a good job, 15 feet in the air dressed in funny clothes.  Now, I'm an unemployed 52 year old with nothing else better to do, and I still get to wondering.  Hopefully, I get it all stuffed out of my head before I hear that first twig snap, the crosshairs come up and the safety comes off.

Publish Post

Thursday, August 05, 2010

What made your most successful hunt successful

My most successful hunts are nearly identical in details.

2003 Opening Day -- The Savage Spoke



2007 Opening Day -- The Savage Spoke Again



The story is real simple:  I went to my favorite stand, climbed up and sat down. Shortly before sunrise, The Big One came out and stood broadside to me at short range. In 2003, it was the first rifle hunt out of this brand new stand.  In 2007, it was a nigh-on repeat, except the buck had   a hat rack considerably larger.

What made the hunts the most successful:

1)  The Rut.  In both cases, the bucks were in a feisty mood.  In 2003, I witnessed a fight between bucks and managed to bag the winner.  In 2007, the lesser bucks were all acting cagey and scared, because the big boy was taking on all comers.  I blew a little half-hearted grunt, and that was all it took to make him come prancing in from a good 200 yards off.

2)  The Stand Location:  I worked for two seasons prior to this trying to find the optimal spot to locate the stand.  I knew this was a hot spot from the beginning, but it had not paid off.  What I had was a saddle offering the best, easiest traverse between two large creek systems.  I had tried several places, and finally positioned a stand on the gully leading away from the western side of the saddle.  In the process, I had tried a similar position on the eastern side of the saddle, as well as near a bedding area further down the western side.  I made my final choice, because I had the best possible view over the most ground. Additionally, I was located in the midst of a stand of oaks that seemed to produce acorns that the deer favored. Truth be told, what really cinched it was the number of remnants of old rotted stands close by.  As best as I can tell this location had been producing since the beginning of the Modern Era.

3)  The Big Picture:  I'm not going to try and kid you about my superior skills as a hunter.  I am in a great spot in a great state.  The farms around my parts have gone from tobacco to beef and are slowly going fallow.  The deer outnumber the people.  We're on the edge of one of the top B&C counties in the state. 


On the emotional side of this, what made these two hunts so good was the feeling of accomplishment.  This was the culmination of 20 years of work, trying to make time despite a lot of important commitments.  It was the pay-off of several years of concerted effort to take the land I had acquired in 2001 and turn it into something better.

The rifle and load were both new in 2003.  I'd been trying to find just the right rifle for me.  This is probably my best stab at it to date:  a Savage 99 in 308 WIN.  The load mimicked a 300 Savage.  This has remained my GOTO gun since.  I am not going to say the rifle made the hunt, but I have to say having a rifle that feels just right does make a difference.  It was worth the effort.

The last thing that made it all successful was that for the first time, in 2007, I got to share it all with all three of my sons.  My younger two sons you have all heard about,  Angus and Moose. They both hunt with me and are becoming avid outdoorsmen.  You usually don't hear about Junior, my oldest, because he doesn't hunt.  He has a bunch of things going on that keeps him out of the field, the biggest one being autism.  For once, he got a chance to come out and be a part of it.  Out of all my hunting experiences, the trophy I probably most treasure is this picture from the Opener in 2007:

Saturday, July 31, 2010

So you STILL want a new Deer Rifle???

This is a continuation from last year's diatribe on deer rifles.

http://blackholecoffeehouse.blogspot.com/2009/06/so-youre-looking-for-new-deer-rifle-huh.html

Which was a thread on D&DH


RE: So you want a new Deer Rifle, huh?



Larry Miller, the comedian, used to do this bit about the five stages of drinking.  As part of one of the stages, you find you have spent arguing for the past hour against Astroturf.  By the end of the next stage, you've argued for Astroturf.  By the end of the five stages you are Astroturf.  

I was thinking about what I wrote last year.  It is kind of obnoxious to leave folks with the impression that my best suggestion for a deer rifle is a Savage 99, which has not been made since 2004, or that my Remington 7600 in 35 Whelen is a great choice as well.  They're both great deer guns for me, but they may not be right for you.  I was looking at my rack this morning and realized I have never found the "ideal" deer rifle.


What would be ideal for me?  Let me take you through a tour of what rolls around in my head.

I used to go plowing through the new color brochures every year, as well as the big wholesaler's catalogs.  When the Internet hit, it wasn't too long before I found I could download them.  I read magazines.  I did my comparisons.  What did I find?  I found I wanted them all.  Then again, I wanted none of them.  Every rifle I saw was a bit of a comprimise.  

At one point in my life, I really wanted a full-stocked Ruger International, but Ruger didn't have it in the chambering I wanted.  Another time, I got really hot on a Remington 700 BDL, but I was leery of the safety.  I thought about doing a custom, but I could not see spending all the money for blasting something as mundane as a deer.    I did finally break down once and buy a Marlin 336 in 30/30 on pure impulse, but as a guy who spent most of his hunting career with a  30-06 , I always found the round anemic. After 30 years of going through this process, I have come to the conclusion that my ideal deer rifle does not exist.  I know parts of rifles I have grown to love.  I doubt I could ever put them all together.

Action:   Probably my favorite actions I own are my lever actions.  I love the Marlin 336, but I am not enamored of a tube magazine.  I love the Savage 99, but I prefer an exposed hammer.   There is also a soft spot in my heart for semi-auto's and pumps.  I started hunting in Ohio, a shotgun state.  Somewhere in the back of my head is a pump deer rifle with a hammer like the Win 1897, or a Browning BLR with a pump instead of a lever.   They just ain't gonna happen. I love the Remington 7600, and I loved my 742, but both have those problematic detachable magazines.   I love my bolt guns too, but. . . well, they're bolt guns.  Really, for just the feel of it, my hands-down favorite is my 54 Hawken caplock.  If looks could kill, the M1 Garand is it for me, but picking up a 10.5 lb deer gun is another thing all together.

Chambering:  Last year, we were also talking about the ideal deer cartridge.  My nominee is the 300 Savage.  Others love the 7mm-08.  However,  I have seen the case made for everything from 223 REM all the way up to 45-70 Govt.   It really does not matter all that much; deer are not that hard to kill.  My point in picking the 300 Savage is that it operates well in the range most hunters encounter most deer, and does so with a reasonable amount of recoil.    A few years ago I embarked on the process of designing the ultimate deer cartridge for myself.  I made two attempts.  One was trying to see if there was room between the 44 Mag and the 444 Marlin for a compromise. There wasn't.  The second attempt used some pretty advanced software that was kind of like the Solver routine in Microsoft Excel on steroids.  I fed in the whole Hodgdon reloading database and told the software to find me the best cartridge for delivering a shot on a deer inside 200 yards, optimizing for a variant of Taylor Knockout (TKO) versus felt recoil.    The software spit out a few suggestions.  One was a 300 Savage load.  Another was a light 35 Whelen load.  It's favorites were a 280 Rem loading and a 6.5X55 Swede. However, if you look at these suggestions, you'll see that a lot popular deer cartridge comes close.   For instance, I'm sure you could use a 140 grain 270 WIN load and mimic the 280 Rem.   You could use a 358 WIN and duplicate the 35 Whelen load.  It's just Hodgdon did not have the data to act as seeds for the program.  The bottom line:  Yes, one of those will do nicely; stay away from the extremes.   

What?  No 30-06?  How can this be?  The truth is that 30-06 and its near-twin 308 WIN are tad overkill.  Overkill's not a bad thing, but remember that we're talking whitetail deer here, and your average shot will probably be inside 100 yards. The 30-06 is still probably the best overall cartridge for North American game, but as a deer cartridge there are those better suited.  My rack is full of  '06 and 308 WIN rifles.  Overkill?  I've hunted groundhog with 30-06.

Safety:  I have had enough problems with safeties over the years, that I just don't trust them.  Whenever I can, I carry with a cold chamber and rely on fast, quiet loading.   I prefer exposed hammers with half-cock safeties, especially with kids.  You can look down and see instantly how the little booger has his safety set.  I also don't mind the extra cross-bolt safety of the Marlin. I only engage it when I'm unloading the magazine.  Ditto for the 3 position safety on bolt actions. However, if you do a lot of carrying with a hot chamber, your requirements for a safety are going to be different.  Safeties should go on and off with as little fuss and as little noise as possible.

Barrel:  Barrel length for normal whitetail conditions is largely a matter of taste.  Shorter barrels reduce velocity, but not to any extent that you're going to have to worry about it at 100 yards.  My Savage 99 is just a hair too long  to be called an absolute joy to hold in my treestand. It gets caught on the shooting rail. On the other hand, I have to say that having a 26" barrel when shooting in a box blind is a godsend, because the farther you have the business end of the rifle outside the box when you pull that trigger the longer your hearing is going to last.  Hint:  blast energy seems to spread out to the side of the barrel more than directly back.  Remember this when you buy a yute rifle for your kid.  

Sights:  My eyes are such that I'm really stuck with telescopic sights.  For my treestand guns, I generally have a 1.5-4.5X variable set to about 2.5X .  Optics are really a whole other subject here, but suffice it to say you should have thought this out before you buy your rifle.  

Magazine:  I have learned to truly detest the metal magazines that Remington has saddled its lines of pump and semi-auto rifles.  They are my least favorite of means of holding cartridges.  Still, I love the rifles.  Tube magazines mean you need flat-nosed bullets; that is not a huge drawback for whitetails.  Probably simple blind box magazines on most of my bolt actions are the best way to go.  I generally load no more than 3 rounds anyway.   if I  have to shoot more than 3 times, you're probably doing something wrong, and it might be a good idea to sit down and catch your composure.

The rest of it?  I like a sling, especially on the long slogs.  I like wood stocks, but I'm getting warmed up to synthetics.  Secretly, I loathe those black rifles Jim Zumbo got all worked up about, but I'm not stupid enough to admit it and I also never get drunk enough to think it is a good idea to have them banned from the hunting woods.  It would also be a bit hypocritical:  I've hunted with an M1 Garand and an SKS.  Just because they're a generation or two older don't mean the idea is any different. Trust me:  it ain't about hunting.  


Afterward:

Probably, if I was going to listen to all that stuff, I might very well go out and buy a Marlin 308 Marlin Express.  But if I really was going to spend that kind of money, I'd probably go get a Browning BLR in 358 WIN-- the one with the pistol grip.  Then again, a nice full-stocked  Ruger MK II International stainless/wood in 7mm-08 still looks good, or  . . . or. . .

From the shamanic archives:

Ode to a 30-30 PT I

Saturday, July 24, 2010

What is the best place to shoot a deer?

From Deer & Deer Hunting



About this time of year, we all get to talking about a list of "bests." What's the best deer caliber? What's the best broadhead? What's the best. . . I remember once having a fellow get on AllOutdoors.com (that's dating me) and ask what was the best camo for squirrel hunting. He had gotten an invite and he had never been before and figured he better buy a new wardrobe. I remember there was a lively discussion that came out of that question. The best?

So where is the best place to aim to kill a deer? I know I can give you my preference. I know when other pro-staffers check in, they'll have theirs. I have reasons. They'll have reasons. I know of some really bum places to hit a deer, but the best?

To start off this discussion, let me throw in a little personal experience on the not-so-good places. I shot my first deer just about 2 O'clock and a couple of inches north of the anus-- a Texas Heart Shot. It was a mistake. The doe crossed in front of me as I was taking aim on a buck. However, the doe went down and died quickly. I had minimal meat loss, and no involvement of the intestines. I was extremely lucky. A quarter century later, I watched my son shoot a small buck with his M1 Garand. The first round hit just behind the near shoulder. The deer did nothing. I encouraged him to take another shot. He was excited and took the second shot a little further back and it emptied out both the chest and abdominal cavities-- again, no serious involvement of the stomach or intestines-- they were laying intact on the ground. When we got to the carcass there was nothing left to clean. My son was extremely lucky. These two instances are fliers. My reason for including them is to show that, in the former, the worst possible situation may not yield bad results, and in the latter the best intentions can sometimes go awry.

I taught my kids that the vitals in the deer can be thought of as a soccer ball sitting in the middle of the rib cage. If you shoot the soccer ball, the animal dies, usually right there in front of you. How you reach that soccer ball is more a matter of taste.

My preference has been to leverage my bow hunting experience as much as possible and shoot for the chest. With a bow, you have a very narrow window of what is going to be an optimum shot. The idea is to get the animal quartering away from you and angle the arrow through the ribs, through both lungs and out the other side. When I became primarily a rifle hunter, I didn't change a whole lot except the optimal quartering-away angle now became more of a straight broadside affair. Most of my shots take out both lungs as well as the top of the heart. With the deer standing broadside, I point my crosshairs where the foreleg meets the body and then rise up about 4 inches up and 4 inches to the rear.

The advantages that I have found to taking this shot are several. In the vast majority of the cases, the animal goes down right there or I can stand where they were shot and see the carcass. The only meat loss is in the thin rib region. The exit wounds can be large if the bullet hits a rib on the way out. The blood trail is significant and short.

The disadvantages to aiming for the lungs and heart? Well, I caught my processor one day when he was having a hard time of it, and asked him if there was a chance he could give me a pack of ribs. Jake looked at me and snapped, "If you wouldn't keep bringing them in with their chests all shot up, I might be able to!" There was truth there. Honestly, I have never been all that attached to venison ribs anyway.

My preference is to stay away from the shoulder. That may be a bias based on my years as a bow hunter. Breaking a shoulder blade and taking out a foreleg, has been largely an unnecessary exercise. The few times I have managed to hit a shoulder blade, the animal went down right there. I suppose you could argue for a preference of meat: do you prefer ribs or shoulder roast? I have the shoulder roasts ground anyway so I get a bit more burger out of each deer. It is a matter of taste.

The advantage as I see to the shoulder shot is that it can preclude running. The disadvantage is that more meat gets torn up. Done right, the shoulder shot does essentially the same thing as chest shot. The lungs and the heart are involved. The animal goes down. Maybe the best thing that can be said for the shoulder shot is that it is farther away from the abdominal cavity than the classic boiler room shot that is my preference.

The Brisket shot: This is my least favorite way to reach the soccer ball, but I've done it. You're reaching the heart and lungs from the front. It's harder to get both lungs and the heart all at once. You also run a good chance of getting into the abdominal cavity. That's always a good spot to avoid. A shot through the front door will bring them down quickly. If they are in close and that is the only shot available, I will take it.

Now let's look at the shots that do not rely on the "Soccer Ball " model:

Gut shots: Ick. If you've ever blown up a stomach or seriously involved the intestines, you know this is not a good idea. The deer dies. How soon is the problem. A got shot deer may last 6 hours and cover a lot of ground in the interim. This is not a good place to aim. I have had two sincere gut shots to deal with in my career. In one case, my son shanked one on a doe, and the animal bedded right there. I finished her when we found her. The second was on a follow-up shot on a buck that I took in 2006. For some reason, the animal took one in the chest and was still alive when I got to him. Hint: deer with their legs drawn up underneath them are not dead. I walked up on him a little too close. The buck jumped up and started to run, and I threw an anchoring shot into him. It anchored him all right-- hit the chest and lungs by way of the stomach. I still retch when I think of cleaning that one out.

The Head Shot: A lot of guys who read military magazines think this one is great. A large number of guys who think they are great shots think this one is great. The problem that I see is as follows: for they guys who read military magazines, this is not the military and the target is not human. The anatomy is different. The motivation is different. Deer generally do not take hostages. I have never seen a deer put a knife to another deer's neck. Deer do not radio your position to artillery. You do not have to worry about return fire. If you take a chest shot at a human, it is hard to take out both lungs and the heart with one round. Front on, the organs don't line up. From the side, you have the arms in the way. Deer also do not wear body armor. The head of a human is also on a much shorter neck and it does not move as much in relation to the body. Yes, done right, the head shot is an instantaneous kill, but if it is slightly off, the deer can have its snout or lower jaw shot off and the wound causes a long lingering death by starvation.

The Neck Shot: Look, no one is going to argue that disruption of the Central Nervous System leads to instant incapacitation. The only arguments I can make against shooting for the neck are similar to head shots. Necks move around a lot. The target is smaller-- we're talking aiming at broomsticks vs. soccer balls. Clipping the esophagus instead of the spinal cord is bummer.

All the others: Having successfully pulled off one accidental Texas Heart Shot in my life, I can tell you that deer can die quickly no matter how bad you screw Wup. Deer shot in the femoral artery can bleed to death very quickly. Deer shot in the spine behind the shoulder blades can drop instantly. Finding the heart and lungs by way of the anus will work if you rifle and stomach are up to punching through all that intervenes. My answer to all these : don't do it.

If you get through thirty seasons and raising two sons into the sport with as few runners and as few lost deer as we have had, we can talk sometime around the campfire about the best place to aim. Until then, I wish you all the best with whatever you pick.


Update: I put up a poll. 88% of the respondents picked the boiler room. 2 picked the shoulder. One said "close to an access road"

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

From D&DH Forum

Everyday Hunter asks: 
 
Is it a moral decision to hunt or not to hunt? 

Let's get philosophical. I recently re-read an article in Sports Illustrated (Nov. 24, 2008) on the decline of hunting. It ended with this sentence:
"Wolves do not make moral decisions, he decided. They just hunt."

So, if hunting is not a matter of morality for wolves, is it for man? Why, or why not?

Steve


My response:

Is hunting moral?  Everything is moral or immoral to one extent or the other.  A lot of it has to do with motivation.   A man can go hunting and follow all of the game rules, engage in Fair Chase, but still commit an immoral act if his intentions are wrong-- say his motivation is to hurt living things.  On the other hand, you have the example of the man who poaches to feed his hungry family.  Is it a reasonable motivation, or is it just a sly excuse to get off being prosecuted?  The question comes down to what is in his heart.

I could say that a man who goes hunting and does not contemplate what he is doing is acting immorally.   However, I would also have to confess that the closest I have have come to achieving Bliss was while I was hunting.  In doing that, I was able to shed thinking altogether.   I could run down the bunny hole further, and say that any man who is not fully aware of what he is doing, aware of where  his weapon is pointed, aware of what lies in the path of the projectile, etc. is acting in an unsafe and therefore immoral manner.  Having said that, I will also say that all that careful thought, as well as the thought of the hunt, the dilemma that we kill so that we may consume life and continue living, the enormity of taking life--   all of that has to be turned off and we need to act in a state of non-thinking so that we can make a successful, ethical shot otherwise we are acting immorally.  When we squeeze the trigger or release our arrow we should be acting mostly out of muscle memory. 

Why I prize hunting is that it brings all this out.  It brings all this out in me.  I learn more about myself in a day in the field than I learn in a year of the rest of my mundane life.  Hunting tempers me.   It brings it out in my sons.  Hunting with them got this fire of ambiguity going in them, and it gave me a chance to show them how I have been dancing with it all these years and let me give them guidance as to how to work with it themselves.  I doubt we would have had the same talks over the years if we had been discussing golf.

Monday, June 28, 2010

High Court’s Big Ruling For Gun Rights -- from Fox News

from:  http://liveshots.blogs.foxnews.com/2010/06/28/high-courts-big-ruling-for-gun-rights/

 

High Court’s Big Ruling For Gun Rights

June 28, 2010 - 10:07 AM | by: Lee Ross
In its second major ruling on gun rights in three years, the Supreme Court Monday extended the federally protected right to keep and bear arms to all 50 states. The decision will be hailed by gun rights advocates and comes over the opposition of gun control groups, the city of Chicago and four justices.
Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the five justice majority saying "the right to keep and bear arms must be regarded as a substantive guarantee, not a prohibition that could be ignored so long as the States legislated in an evenhanded manner."
The ruling builds upon the Court's 2008 decision in D.C. v. Heller that invalidated the handgun ban in the nation's capital. More importantly, that decision held that the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms was a right the Founders specifically delegated to individuals. The justices affirmed that decision and extended its reach to the 50 states. Today's ruling also invalidates Chicago's handgun ban.
Backgrounder:
WASHINGTON -- The Supreme Court appears poised to issue a ruling that will expand to the states the high court's historic 2008 ruling that individuals have a federally protected right to keep and bear arms, following an hour-long argument Tuesday. If so, the decision would mark another hallmark victory for gun rights advocates and likely strike down Chicago's handgun ban that is similar to the Washington D.C. law already invalidated by the justices.
Tuesday's lively arguments featured lawyer Alan Gura, the same man who argued and won D.C. v. Heller in 2008. He now represents Otis McDonald who believes Chicago's handgun ban doesn't allow him to adequately protect himself. Gura argued the Heller decision which only applied to Washington D.C. and other areas of federal control should equally apply to Chicago and the rest of the country.
"In 1868, our nation made a promise to the McDonald family that they and their descendants would henceforth be American citizens, and with American citizenship came the guarantee enshrined in our Constitution that no State could make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of American citizenship," Gura told the Court.
He argued the language of the Constitution's 14th Amendment forces the states to protect the rights guaranteed by the Second Amendment. The Bill of Rights, which was adopted in the late 18th Century, was then commonly viewed as only offering protections from the federal government.
It wasn't until after the Civil War that the Supreme Court in a piecemeal fashion began to apply--or incorporate--parts of the Bill of Rights to the states. It has used the 14th Amendment's Due Process Clause to incorporate most of the Constitution's first amendments but has not yet done so for the Second Amendment. Gura argued that another part of the 14th Amendment would be a better vehicle for the justices to make their ruling but there didn't appear to be enough support from the bench on that front.
Chief Justice John Roberts was the most vocal advocate of using the Due Process Clause to extend the Second Amendment rights to the states. "I don't see how you can read -- I don't see how you can read Heller and not take away from it the notion that the Second Amendment...was extremely important to the framers in their view of what liberty meant."
The discussion over "liberty" was a major philosophical theme of the arguments. Gura and National Rifle Association lawyer Paul Clement argued that the rights articulated in the Second Amendment are fundamental freedoms and would exist to all Americans even if there was no law specifically saying so.
James Feldman, lawyer for the City of Chicago, defended his city's handgun ban and argued why the Heller decision's Second Amendment guarantee doesn't comport with the view that it represents a vital protection of liberty that needs to be expanded to the states.
"[T]he right it protects is not implicit in the concept of ordered liberty," Feldman said. "States and local governments have been the primary locus of firearms regulation in this country for the last 220 years. Firearms unlike anything else that is the subject of a provision of the Bill of Rights are designed to injure and kill."
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented in Heller and wondered why the right to bear arms was necessary to extend to the states. "[I]f the notion is that these are principles that any free society would adopt, well, a lot of free societies have rejected the right to keep and bear arms."
Later in the arguments Roberts disputed that notion. "I do think the focus is our system of ordered liberty, not any abstract system of ordered liberty. You can say Japan is a free country, but it doesn't have the right to trial by -- by jury."
Roberts was part of the five member majority in Heller and there's a good chance Tuesday's case will result in a similar 5-4 outcome. All of the members of the Heller majority are still on the Court and at least one of them would have to rule against extending the Second Amendment protection in order for the opposing side to prevail.
Tags

Tuesday, June 01, 2010

Come On! Really?

You know, the more I think about this whole Scent Lok thing the more annoyed I get. You figure an entire generation of hunters has been working under these assumptions about scent management. I am not saying scent management is bogus, but I am saying that Scent Lok and its ilk have certainly muddied the waters. For 20 years we've been hearing experts tell us this is one of the primary keys to successful deer hunting. I would be the first to admit that a lot of my thought has been down those same lines. I never did agree with Scent Lok's claims, but I always figured there must be something to the issue. My whole view of hunting has been clouded by this detritus-- and I never even bought one of their stinking suits.

Look at WoodsWalker. He's big on his ghillie suit. Mine has languished for years in the closet. Why? Part of it was that I found the suit to be overkill for my type of hunting. Part of it was that I was not all that comfortable in it. However, a major component of my dislike for the suit was that always stank of wet jute and no matter what I did, I could not get that stink out of it. Well ( DUH!) maybe Woodsie is right, and maybe a ghillie suit is the way to go, and it doesn't matter that it stinks like jute or hemp or that you can't throw it in a washer and do it in baking soda. It just may work, because the deer don't care.

Or cigarettes. Take ciggies. I know a bunch of guys who smoke-- here in KY it's more the rule than other places nowadays. They're successful deer hunters. How can this be? The deer don't care? If they don't care about that stink and they didn't care about whatever stench was leaking out of the Scent Lok suits and they don't care about rank, stanky ghillie suits. . . DANG! What do they care about.

Human urine? Nope, I know that ain't true. Human poopoo? If Scent Lok don't work and all these guys have been farting in their Scent Lok suits for 20 years. . . well, you do the figgerin', Braniac.

And what about all these experts that were telling us scent management was so important and how you really needed one of these stinking charcoal suits if you were going to be serious about the sport. Now what? Where they taken in by the fraud knowingly or unknowingly. Did they all go running off the cliff together like lemmings, or did they pull this off like a bunch of Chicago politicians. Are these guys rogues or rubes? My feeling is the the answer is, yes. One of those will do nicely.


I'm going to tell you a story to explain my answer. Take out of it what you want. Back when I was first getting into hunting, I acquired a neat little book. It was the 1939 edition of the Outdoor Life 'Cyclopedia. It was a wonderful little compendium of everything you could think of for the outdoors: fishing, camping, hunting, shooting, hiking. I treasured it. In fact, I have scrounged up more copies of it over the years so my sons would each have a copy. It wasn't until I got the farm that I got to try some of the stuff they suggested. A lot of it you can't do on public land or in a public campground anymore. Once I had my own place, I could do what I wanted.

Example: Here's the dream:




Here's the reality:


I tried for two season to build a hearth like the one in the book. There was no freakin' way that was going to work, and there was no freakin' way that hearth could be put together for a short-term camp that made any sense. Pounding that many stakes in was ridiculous, filling up the interior with that much dirt was ridiculous, and after one rain, the whole thing started to settle, lean, fall apart, and otherwise disintegrate.


I should have known better. They also had this picture in the book:


My comments from the summation of this project:

[quote]

Yeah right!

Okay, here are some study questions:

1) How many trees were cut down in the making of this home away from home?

2) Who the heck would actually build all that stuff for "but a few days"

3) Are they still selling the stuff he was taking without prescription?

4) Imagine trying to pull this off in a State Park Campground. How long would that last?

5) Imagine if you saw these two men in the woods today. I count only one mattress. Would you be expecting the wives to show up at any minute?

Imagine the caption : ". . . So I said to Bruce, 'Oh you wicked, girl! I was going as Bette Midler's Gift from the Oceans, and you stole my whole costume idea.'"

I see this as a new show on the Outdoor Channel: Queer Eye for the Straight Camper.
[/quote]

The stuff on hunting was just as bad. Some interesting facts from this tome:

1) Turkeys have to go to water first thing in the morning after they hop down off the roost. Therefore, the best way to hunt turkeys is to situate yourself between the water and the turkeys and ambush them.
2) Deer hunting with buckshot is a highly effective method out to 80 yards. At 80 yards, the average shotgun shooting 00 will put half a dozen pellets into the chest of a running deer. They even had a drawing.

The list goes on and on.

The point is that this compendium of knowledge of the outdoors was really a pile of drivel, put together by a bunch of fey city slickers that really had no idea what was going on in the outdoors. However, if they dressed it up and made it look good, guys would buy the book. That was the 1930's. Honest and truly, I don't think the folks who put out the drivel these days are any more in tune with reality than what they were back then. I'm not going to paint the whole lot of them with the same brush. However, between the urge to make money, the urge to make reputation, the urge to make deadline, and the urge to go with the flow, I don't think many people who create content for the consumption of hunters really have much room left for original thinking, critical thinking, or (for some at least) ethical thinking. D&DH is an exception in this, but D&DH also has to address their own involvement with Scent Lok over the years. I feel no one in the industry is immune from this. Everyone has Scent Lok's taint all over them right now.

What about me? First off, no one ever confused me with an expert on deer hunting. Second, I've been saying Scent Lok was goofy in both intent and execution from the get-go. However, I'm the first to say that scent management as a concept has ruled my deer hunting life since about 2 years prior to Scent Lok first showing up. It has only been in the past 3 or 4 years I have even started to question the extent of my anti-scent compulsion. It has only been since this Scent Lok decision came down that I have realized how totally taken in I am ( even though I was a Scent Lok skeptic) and started asking the hard question: What's really the truth here?

Thursday, May 27, 2010

I Just Don't Get it

For every crazy instance I have in the past 30 years of deer busting me at some un-believable range, I have one or more crazy stories about deer that walk up on me while I'm taking a dump or eating my lunch, coming to watch me erect a stand, or while I'm climbing into my stand.

My point here is that we've all had these various mindsets, mostly around a deer's fantastic senses of hearing and smell. Now all of a sudden we find out the fancy scent suits weren't working. Instead of being invisible to the deer, thousands of hunters over 20 years were running round the forest in overpriced rain suits. That has to say something about the original premise.

Here's a mind bender for you. Let me set up a situation. This has happened to me more than once. The property I'm on is divided roughly down the top of the ridge by a treeline following an abandoned road that follows the top of the ridge. It affords the easiest access to the back of the property. It also passes across the top of several hollows, and it frequently happens that I'll bust up deer on my way down that road, either bedding or loafing at the tops of these hollows.

Now, I try my best to get past them when I'm on the way to the stand, but sometimes it just doesn't work. I try to keep my scent managed as well, but sometimes I slip up. I may have grabbed yesterday's shirt by accident or whatever. The deer are quick to let me know. But here's the weird part. Often times, the deer don't run away. They snort, they stamp, but then they follow me a hundred yards down the way and they bust me again, and will keep this up for a half mile. It's like they're playing a game of "You Stink!" and I'm the stinker.

We see a similar version of this when we're camping. The deer know we're there. The deer can smell the campfire and the other various stinks plainly. Yet, they come up close to the tents and bust us as if they're surprised. On a 3 day campout, it gets to be a quite humorous--the same deer, the same time of day. It's a variation of the You Stink! game.

To a lesser extent, I see a third variation of "You Stink." I will bust a doe when I'm out and about on the farm. That doe will then circle and come up on me 2-4 additional times, usually circling from upwind to downwind, and repeatedly bust me. Once should be enough for a deer, especially when it's a hard bust.

Now what's up with that? If I am really perceived as a threat, why keep coming back? It's me. You know it's me. I've been this way lots of times before, what's your point?

Why I think it is important that we keep questioning all this is that deer don't seem to think about us the same way we would think of a predator. If they're deliberately encountering a potential predator, that speaks of a different sort of motivation. I'm not going to fall into the trap of saying "You Stink" is really a human-type game. However, there's got to be a component to it that is different from our way of thinking.

Along with the buck-in-the-bushes chestnut, there are two more that stick in my head from my early days. Maybe you've heard them. One involved the idea that you could lure deer in by playing a radio, soft and low in the woods. The idea was that you took a transistor radio, tuned it to a music station and then put it on a stump and stood back and waited. The other was that a deer hunter could lure in deer by cooking his lunch over an open fire. The former was one I never got around to trying. I did try cooking my lunch in the woods a couple of times. Nothing ever showed up, and then I got into the whole scent reduction kick and figured it was not a good idea to be sitting around a campfire if I wanted to stay scent-free.

Let's just say for a second these worked. Let's just say deer really do get out and play "You Stink" and saw the radio trick and the hot lunch trick as a chance to count coup on us. For the past 25 years we've been poo-pooing these tricks as superstitions, sitting there all fat and happy in our Scent Lok suits, sprayed down with UV Killer. It makes you think, don't it?

BTW: I saw a version of the radio trick a few years ago, but I don't think the hunter had it right. He rode out on his ATV, parked by the property line and turned on his boom box and played heavy metal head banging music as loud as he could while glassing for deer. After 15 minutes, he rode off, and you could hear the heavy metal playing over on the next ridge and the next until it finally disappeared. My guess is that he had been watching TV too much and thought you had to bring your own background music on the hunt.

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Towards a New Understanding

I caught myself this morning while I was writing a response to a fellow on another forum who was defending his use of Scent Lok clothes.

I would agree up to a point. Reducing the amount of stink your body is throwing off is a good idea. The results can be dramatic too. However, I have also had some experiences where it caused me to doubt the whole premise.

I had two nice bucks in velvet IN my turkey blind this season. They came in on the downwind side too. In fact, I have had several encounters like that over the years in the off-season. I am left to conclude that deer are at least seasonal in their worries about humans.

I have shot deer on Saturday and had the same herd back under the same stand on Sunday. I have also shot deer and had their neighbors go on munching grass. Even more dramatic, I shot The Big One back in 2007 and had to wait a half hour while other bucks came out and sparred under the stand after I shot their Boss. The stand I shot him from was adjacent to the family campground, and we go there frequently throughout the summer.

I am beginning to question exactly how in tune deer are with the whole concept of their own mortality, and exactly what we are doing out there in the woods. Mind you, this comes from a guy who has 200 acres all to himself, and I am on the property most of the year doing things that show no threat to the deer. I am sure that in high-pressure areas things may be different. However, I am more and more convinced that the idea of crawling into a $300 charcoal suit and forgetting the wind is far too simplistic a view.

What the heck am I saying here? Look, I am still not sure that we have a good handle on this thing. Think about what it means with Scent Lok going down in flames last week. It means a LOT of experts, folks we trusted for their opinions on deer behavior were caught wearing what amounts to a $300 rabbit's foot. Yikes! What does this mean?

If I look back on what I was being fed to me in the way of serious deer hunting knowledge back in the late-70's and early 80's, it was largely superstition and anecdotal advice. If I look back farther, and I have a collection of some nice books going back to the early 1900's, there is a lot of the same. Folks did not really understand deer. They were largely extirpated, and it has only been recently that the herd sizes have grown to the point where they could be observed as anything more than a set of tracks and an occasional white flag in the woods.

My feeling is that we're still stumbling for the truth. Do not get me wrong. Wearing a three day pit stink in a treestand is still counter-productive in my eyes. However, I am going back and seriously reassessing what I have seen over the years and trying to filter it through new eyes.

Let's just assume that Scent Lok's claims are bogus. That means that folks have been putting on these suits that don't work and going out in the woods. Some of these hunters have been claiming terrific results. My first response to this is that something else that they did, namely addressing other issues of personal hygiene and laundry reduced their scent signature and affected the outcome.

But is that all there is to it? My personal feeling is no. I think the new understanding needs to go deeper. I don't have answers either, only questions. For instance, I've been around cattle more in the past decade than at any other time in my life. The neighbors farm beef cattle. I have even let them pasture a few on our place at times. What impresses me about these beasts is that they are not dumb. They are pretty intelligent, but unlike horses, they seem to have a world view that makes it hard for humans to cozy up to them. It's an alien mindset, very oriented to the herd. Humans are tolerated, but with a high degree of what seems to be mistrust. I am not saying deer are like cows. However, the more I am around cows, the more I can see where I just don't get them, and they just don't get me. It means I probably don't get it with deer either and vice versa.

What if their ideas about us are different? What if we fundamentally do not understand them? What if they don't have the same understanding of mortality? Of prey/predator? Outdoor writers are taught not to anthropomorphize animals-- put human ideas into their heads. However, what if we have not gone deep enough in this?

I go back to one fundamental understanding I had when I started deer hunting. A bunch of people told me a basic truth: if you see doe come through, get ready. The bucks will prod the doe with their antlers and send them out ahead to see if their is danger. Every time I saw doe, those first few years, I always held off shooting. I always figured there was a buck somewhere in the bushes and if I waited, he would show himself.

Bunk. Of course we all know now that bucks are chasing doe in the fall. They prod them with their antlers to try and get them to breed. When doe are not ready they run off. This is the Chase Phase of the rut. However, look how that one erroneous piece of anecdotal fiddle-faddle fundamentally screwed up my whole view of hunting deer. I went through 5 seasons waiting for that buck to come out of the dang bushes.

Now we have come to a crossroads. If you assume that this Scent Lok thing really is bunk, we really need to reassess what it means. We have taken for granted that scent reduction/elimination was a fundamental pillar of contemporary deer hunting, but here are all these experts telling us "Wait! Them doe's is just scouts. There's a buck back in those bushes somewhere!" Remember that as the herds were growing two decades ago, we were all being fed the idea that scent management was a primary concern and a generation of hunters have all relied on this basic fact, just as I did the buck-in-the-bushes tale.

As a fellow who not only believed there was a buck waiting in the bushes, but saw it with my own eyes, I can tell you that having your underlying understanding skewed really horses up what you think you're seeing. If I had not picked up a copy of D&DH magazine and seriously begun to read up on the rut, I would still be out there seeing doe running through the forest and waiting for the buck to come out. I am going back and trying to re-evaluate my vision of how scent management has factored into my deer hunting, and I think we should all do the same. What have we observed and not really seen? What have we seen and misinterpreted? What have we failed to recognize, because we assumed scent-management was the answer?

As I said, these are questions. I'm just asking them. I don't have the answer.